Cals › Pies & sausage rolls › Compare › Herbert Adams Pies Chunky Slow Cooked Beef & Mush 2 pack vs National Pies Frozen Classic Pastie 180g
Herbert Adams Pies Chunky Slow Cooked Beef & Mush 2 pack vs National Pies Frozen Classic Pastie 180g
Per 100 g, Herbert Adams Pies Chunky Slow Cooked Beef & Mush 2 pack has more meat (15% vs 11%), less sugar (1.5 vs 2), less sodium (396 vs 616) than National Pies Frozen Classic Pastie 180g.
Same aisle, measurably different composition. Every number is verified against independent supplier feeds and the labels photographed on pack.
Herbert Adams Pies Chunky Slow Cooked Beef & Mush 2 pack15% meat
vs
National Pies Frozen Classic Pastie 180g11% meat
Protein (higher)
9.2 vs 5.9 g
sugars (lower)
1.5 vs 2 g
Sodium (lower)
396 vs 616 mg
More meat
15% vs 11%
Energy (lower)
951 vs 1070 kJ
Fat, total (lower)
10.7 vs 13.4 g
saturated (lower)
5.2 vs 6.6 g
Side by side, per 100 g
| Value | Herbert Adams | National Pies |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | 1070 kJ (256 Cal) | 951 kJ (227 Cal) |
| Protein | 9.2 g | 5.9 g |
| Fat, total | 13.4 g | 10.7 g |
| - saturated | 6.6 g | 5.2 g |
| Carbohydrate | 25.2 g | 25.8 g |
| - sugars | 1.5 g | 2 g |
| Sodium | 396 mg | 616 mg |
✓ marks a difference beyond label-rounding tolerance.
What’s in each pack
Herbert Adams: Australian Wheat Flour, Australian Beef (Min 25%) (Slow-Cooked Beef (15%), Minced Beef), Water, Margarine (Animal Fats, Vegetable Oils, Water, Salt, Emulsifiers
15% meat
National Pies: Vegetable Mix (Potato (23%), Carrot (15%)), Wheat Flour, Mashed Potato (Water, Potato Flakes (Contains Stabiliser (450), Preservative (222)(Sulphites)), Margari
11% meat